13 FEB 2024
Collaborative session notes https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TU1nEzYDdg3vRW6OIAQER9lxkYy2Z2qiVjPSABf_GwA/edit?usp=drive_link
Group(s) submitting the application:
Meeting objectives:
The group has identified a citation problem, sought use cases which seek to address complex citations and worked on potential solutions. In sharing existing pilots that attempt to address the problem of complex citations as the complex citation working group seek to share their progress on the proposed solutions based on their use cases and identify the benefits and shortfalls of the solutions as the group looks towards providing recommendations. The group will offer additional use cases beyond the existing examples and identifying landmarks for the remaining working group lifetime.
Meeting agenda:
- 0-5 Minutes (5 minutes): Welcome and introduction – Shelley
- 5-15 Minutes (10 minutes): Overview of the group, achievements so far and plans for next 6 months (including hackathons) – Shelley Stall
- 15 – 25 (10 minutes): What does it mean to enable attribution of all members of a reliquary? Shelley Stall
- 25 – 45 (20 minutes) Presentation of Prototypes – Martina Stockhause (IPCC figues and attribution) Joan Damerow (Physical Samples)
- 45 – 55 (10 minutes) Growing the PID graph to portray use cases – Justin Buck
- 55 – 75 (20 mintues) Discussion and feedback on prototypes – Shelley Stall
- 75 – 85 (10 minutes): Planning the final stretch: Who is doing what and by when, Hackathon Topics and Schedule – Shelley Stall
- Potential Hackathon topics:
- Potential ther protypes
- How do we enable attribution
- Transparency and provenance of each member of reliquary
- Potential Hackathon topics:
- 85 – 90 Minutes (5 MInutes): Closing circle – Lesley Wyborn
Target Audience:
Although the definition of the problem initially comes from the Earth, Space and Environmental Science, we want to engage with the broad RDA community to see if other areas have a similar issue. We are especially inviting those with interest in PIDs (re: DOIs), FAIR Digital Objects, DataCite Collections, repositories creating DOI collections, journals supporting citing DOI Collections, and Credit for the elements of a DOI Collection.
We particularly seek input from:
- Researchers that need to cite more than 10 research artifacts/objects in a research paper to help define the problem and fully develop the recommendations and identify adopters.
- Journal staff and indexers to help develop a basic approach that applies to most variations and comment on some of the early drafts of the recommendations.
Group chair serving as contact person:
Brief introduction describing the activities and scope of the group:
- Starting in December 2020 during a Data FAIR Town Hall at AGU’s Fall meeting we reached out across the community for interest in supporting virtual working sessions that would lead to recommendations, adoption, and a better of citing large numbers of data/digital objects in journal articles and other publications.
- During 2021 we held three large working sessions as well as smaller group development efforts, which are documented at. https://data.agu.org/DataCitationCoP/
The discussion was continued at a BoF at RDA-19: the BoF “Complex Data Citations: Formulating a Community Recommendation” session, which led to the formation of the Working Group.
Short Group Status:
- We were established as a Working Group in February 2023
- We meet regularly between plenaries.
- We have held sessions at plenaries as follows:
- RDA P20 (March 2023): Complex Citations in the Earth and Space Sciences: Formulating Requirements for a Demonstration Prototype
- RDA P21 (October 2023): Complex Citations: Next steps towards a Demonstration Prototype
- We are due to complete in August 2024.
Type of Meeting:
Working meeting
Additional links to informative material:
- International Data Week 2023: Session notes and recording
- Website: https://data.agu.org/DataCitationCoP/
- Workshop Materials and links to recordings
- Agarwal, Deborah, Coward, Caroline, Stall, Shelley, & Erdmann, Christopher. (2021, April). Data Citation Community of Practice – 8 April 2021 Workshop. Zenodo. http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4673622
- Agarwal, Deborah, Goble, Carole, Soiland-Reyes, Stian, Sarkans, Ugis, Noesgaard, Daniel, Schindler, Uwe, Fenner, Martin, Manghi, Paolo, Stall, Shelley, Coward, Caroline, Erdmann, Chris, 2021. Data Citation Community of Practice – 8 June 2021 Workshop. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4916734
- Stall, Shelley, Buck, Justin, Ayliffe, James, Stockhause, Martina, Agarwal, Deb, Coward, Caroline, & Erdmann, Chris. (2021, October 29). Data Citation Community of Practice – 29 October 2021 Workshop. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5641236
Avoid conflict with the following group (1):
Avoid conflict with the following group (2):
Meeting presenters:
Shelley Stall, Justin Buck, Martina Stockhause, Joan Damerow, Lesley Wyborn
Are you willing to host a second, repeat, session at a different time zone?:
No