status: Recognised & Endorsed

Chair (s): Hea Lim Rhee, Francis P. Crawley, Rory Macneil, Adam Vials Moore, Emmanuel Adamolekun

Group Email: [group_email]

Secretariat Liaison: [field_secretariat_liaison]


RDA-OfR Mapping the landscape of digital research tools WG

NOTE: WG name changed from 'Mapping the digital research data infrastructure landscape WG'

Scroll to the bottom of this page for all WG meeting documentation

 

Overview

The digital research data infrastructure landscape comprises a myriad of tools for managing and sharing research data during various stages of the research data lifecycle. Such research tools vary widely depending on data type, user requirement, provider, and subject area. In the context of this WG, research ‘tools enable researchers to perform one or more operations, typically on data, and often with data as the output. Tools are usually intended for use by humans. In this context we are explicitly excluding physical instruments.’

 

The diversity and variety of research tools can prove overwhelming and challenging for stakeholders working within the digital research data ecosystem to understand, navigate, and select the most appropriate tool to meet their needs and objectives. The categorisation of research tools, based on their features, functionalities and how they interoperate, remains unclear. In many cases, research tools are not interoperable, often leading to siloed working within organisations and disciplines, thereby limiting the scope of research and the ability to share and reuse data. 

 

This RDA Working Group (WG), supported by Oracle for Research (OfR), aims to address these challenges by: (i) categorising different types of research tools; and, (ii) mapping different types of research tools to the research data lifecycle based on their features and functionalities. 

 

Deliverables 

The WG will produce a categorisation schema (a conceptual framework) of research tool types that includes terminology, definitions and associated metadata describing features and functionalities of different tool types. The categorisation schema will be stored in an autonomous database provided by Oracle Cloud Infrastructure. The WG will undertake the following programme of work to achieve its deliverables:

 

The creation of a research data lifecycle model and crosswalk to existing models (Deliverable 1)

 

The WG will examine and identify the different stages of the research data lifecycle. Since numerous different models of the research data lifecycle exist that have been conceptualised for specific research paradigms and audiences, the WG will conduct a landscape review to research and consult existing models (see Section 3) and identify common stages of the research data lifecycle for use as the framework to guide the research tool categorisation. Each research data lifecycle stage will be supported by terminology and definitions. The WG will create a crosswalk to demonstrate connections between the chosen model and existing models. 

 

The identification, categorisation, and mapping of different types of research tools: A categorisation schema (Deliverable 2)

 

The WG will research and consult existing work in the area to identify, categorise, and map different types of research tools. Such tools may include, but are not limited to: open science frameworks, data management planning tools, electronic laboratory notebooks (ELNs), laboratory information management systems (LIMS), virtual research environments (VREs), databases, repositories, and archives. Types of research tools will be described, categorised, and mapped to the research data lifecycle framework based on their utility, and assessed based on their interoperability. 

 

The aim of this deliverable is to highlight the potential for and current limitations of streamlined flow of research data and metadata throughout the research data lifecycle based on how different types of research tools interoperate. This will be highly valuable in the context of the development of the national and international open research commons. 

 

This work will contribute to and build on the work of the RDA’s Global Open Research Commons IG and GORC International Model WG. Task Group 5 of the GORC International WG has undertaken an extensive literature review and released a Commons Attributes Model (Version 0.5) that identifies a suite of services and tools that will inform the work of this WG. Efforts to describe the features, functionality, and interoperability of different types of research tools will complement the development of the ‘Commons Integration Roadmap’ (GORC WG Deliverable) by providing key information about different types of research tools, and highlighting areas for the improvement of their interoperability and user experience. 

 

The creation of a preliminary structural framework for an online open access ‘map of the digital research tool landscape’ (Deliverable 3)

 

The WG will undertake the necessary foundational work required to create an autonomous relational database that is hosted by the RDA Foundation (as a legal entity on behalf of the RDA), owned by the community, and powered by Oracle for Software. This arrangement has been discussed and agreed by RDA and Oracle for Research. 

 

The open access database, navigable by research data lifecycle stage, will: (i) contain searchable information (e.g., features, functionalities, interoperability) about different types of research tools; and: (ii) allow for ongoing community curation and further development. The WG will provide recommendations for the long-term maintenance, sustainability, and adoption of the database to ensure that it remains current, relevant, and useful for the research data community. Such recommendations will also propose methodologies for future community-curation (detailing who can contribute and how), management, and governance of the database. 

 

The ultimate goal is to provide the research data community with a dynamic resource that remains up to date with newly emerging types of research tools and evolves with the ever-changing digital research data infrastructure landscape. This may include significant data and software-related developments, e.g., Artificial Intelligence (AI).

 

Meetings and Deliverables (see WG meeting folder

Date (2023-2024)

 Topic

Documentation and Deliverables 

23 April 2023   

Brainstorming workshops: Definition of WG scope  

22 May

1st WG meeting: Revision of case statement   

 

29 June  

2nd WG meeting: Creating/Selecting a Research Data Life Cycle Model - The Discovery Phase

  • Kickstarting the WG
  • Discovery phase: Collecting research data life cycle models in breakouts - formation of task groups 
     
20 July 

3rd WG meeting: Creating/Selecting a Research Data Life Cycle Model - The Harmonisation Phase 

  • Discovery phase: Presentation of research data life cycle models by group nominated leads/rapporteur(s) 
  • Harmonisation phase: Crosswalk of research data life cycle models and selection of a framework to guide categorisation schema for types of research tool   
17 August     

4th WG meeting: Finalisation of Deliverable 1 - Creation/selection of a Research Data Life Cycle Model 

  • Presentation of harmonised research data life cycle model (MaLDReTH) by co-chairs
  • Selection and/or creation of harmonised terminologies and definitions of each research data lifecycle stage
  • Finalisation of the model and suggestions for next steps
14 September                    

5th WG meeting: A roadmap for the creation of a categorisation schema of research tools 

 

 

9 October              

6th WG meeting: Approach to Deliverable 2 (Categorisation Schema of research tools) 

  • Start of the landscape review to collect research tools used during the 'Publication' stage of the MaLDReTH Research Data Lifecycle Model

 

26 October             

7th WG meeting: Mapping the landscape of digital research tools working meeting 

Breakout session 5: 07:00 - 08:30 UTC (P21 session programme)
The aim of this working meeting is to present the new RDA-OfR Mapping the Landscape of Digital Research Tools WG and receive feedback, input, and further direction on the WG’s aims, objectives, methodologies, and deliverables as well as expand the WG’s collaborations within RDA and attract an expanded and more diverse WG membership.

 

9 November 

8th WG meeting: Post-plenary 'Pause and reflect' meeting 

  • Reflection on the P21 Plenary session 
7 December 

9th WG meeting: Building upon the work of the Global Open Research Commons (GORC) International Model WG

 

13 December 

10th WG meeting: Formation of Task Groups to finalise Deliverable 2: Turning the landscape review into a categorisation schema of research tools

  • Create 4 task groups, each task group covers 3 stages of the research data life cycle model. 
  • Identify top 3-4 representative, typical tools for description.
  • Identify tools that are present across more than one stage of the research data lifecycle. 
  • Add column in the spreadsheet to include ‘disciplinary or generic’.
  • Add column in the spreadsheet to include a note/acknowledgement about interoperability.
25 January 

11th WG meeting: Finalising Deliverable 2 - A categorisation schema of different types of research tools 

  • To learn about Invest in Open Infrastructure product

  • To finalise Deliverable 2 and discuss the next steps for the WG 
     

22 February  12th WG meeting: Finalising Deliverable 2 and Planning Deliverable 3 - Creation of an online, open access map of the digital research tool landscape 
 
 
           

Posts

22
February
2024

Thank you - Mapping the landscape WG update

by Connie Clare

Dear WG members, Thank you to those who attended the RDA-OfR Mapping the landscape of digital research tools WG meeting earlier today. Meeting documentation During the meeting, the group briefly discussed outstanding tasks for the completion of the ‘Categorisation Schema of Digital Research Tools’ and provided initial thoughts and feedback on the visual map of digital research tools mapped to research data lifecycle stage. Please see the collaborative notes and meeting recording - Passcode: $pUHy96p Finalising Deliverables in 2 months
2 | Add new comment
21
February
2024

Tomorrow's meeting: Mapping the landscape of digital research tools

by Connie Clare

Dear WG members, I hope you are all doing well and are having a good week so far. The countdown is on! It is approximately 2 months until the WG is due to submit its deliverables to the Secretariat. Our 12th Working Group meeting takes place tomorrow Thursday 22 February, 12:00-13:30 UTC. During the meeting, the WG aims to: * Continue describing the categories of research tools found in the different research data lifecycle stages.
1 | Add new comment
15
February
2024

WG Facilitation Feedback Survey - A Short Report

by Connie Clare

Dear WG members, I hope you are all having a good week. I would like to share this report providing an overview of the results of the RDA-OfR WG Facilitation Feedback Survey with you. The survey was open for >6 weeks (Dec 2023 to Jan 2024) and completed by nine WG members. Thank you to those individuals who completed the survey, your feedback was highly valuable and will be used to improve facilitations services provided by the RDA in the future.
0 | Add new comment
12
February
2024

Re: [rda-ofr-mapping-landscape-digital-tools] RE: Mapping the landscape WG - P22 Session Proposal Submission

by Connie Clare

Thank you for your email, Francis, and for raising this access issue. Apologies if members cannot view the submission, it might be that as it has not been approved it is private for now. I have attached the draft text for your interest. Thanks, and best wishes, Connie Connie Clare, PhD Community Development Manager Research Data Alliance Foundation Tel: +44-7545342802 email: ***@***.***-foundation.org Twitter: @ConnieEClare
0 | Add new comment
12
February
2024

RE: Mapping the landscape WG - P22 Session Proposal Submission

by Francis P. Crawley

Dear Connie, Thank you for this note. I received the following 'Access denied' when trying to view the submission: [A screenshot of a website Description automatically generated] Just so you know. No big deal. I am sure it is fine. Kind regards, Francis Mobile: +32 495 23 11 11 From: Connie Clare <***@***.***-foundation.org> Sent: Monday, February 12, 2024 11:37 AM To: Connie Clare via RDA-OfR Mapping the landscape of digital research tools WG <***@***.***-groups.org>
0 | Add new comment
12
February
2024

Mapping the landscape WG - P22 Session Proposal Submission

by Connie Clare

Dear all WG members, P22 Session Proposal Submitted Earlier today co-chair Rory Macneil and I submitted the P22 session submission on behalf of the WG. Please see the full submission details for the session titled ‘Creating a Categorisation Schema of Digital Research Tools Mapped to the Research Data Lifecycle’.
0 | Add new comment
29
January
2024

Last chance: Please provide your feedback!

by Connie Clare

RDA-OfR Mapping the landscape of digital tools WG: Facilitation services and support. Dear WG members, For those of you who have been actively participating in the Mapping the landscape of digital research tools WG over the past year, I would like to invite you to please provide your feedback on the facilitation services offered by the Secretariat. For context…
0 | Add new comment
26
January
2024

RDA-OfR Mapping the Landscape WG - Follow-up

by Connie Clare

Dear WG members, Thank you to those who attended the RDA-OfR Mapping the Digital Research Data Infrastructure Landscape WG meeting yesterday. Meeting documentation During the meeting, the group discussed the next steps for finalising Deliverable 2: Categorisation schema of research tools – deadline Thursday 22 February. Please see the collaborative notes and recording (passcode: .1UeR.MG) Next steps
0 | Add new comment
26
January
2024

RDA-OfR Mapping the Digital Research Data Infrastructure Landscape WG meeting

by Connie Clare

Dear all WG members, Please see our next meeting invitation series for the RDA-OfR Mapping the Digital Research Data Infrastructure Landscape WG Meetings Working meetings will take place every 4 weeks (Thursday) at 12:00 – 13:30 UTC. * Zoom link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83051120541?pwd=N0hSZGtvVGt3UFRQRTFEc0NUTndaZz09 * Documentation (presentation slides, collaborative notes) and deliverables can be found at the bottom of the WG webpage.
0 | Add new comment
23
January
2024

Reminder: Next Mapping the Landscape WG meeting

by Connie Clare

Dear WG members, This is a kind reminder about our 11th Working Group meeting which will take place on Thursday 25 January, 12:00-13:30 UTC. During this meeting, we will: * Learn about a new product created by Invest in Open Infrastructure which aids the selection of research tools. * Discuss the status of Deliverable 2: Categorisation Schema of Research Tools and next steps for its finalisation. * Discuss a session proposal and suitable breakout slots for the RDA’s 22nd Plenary (May 2024)
0 | Add new comment

Pages