Skip to main content

Notice

The new RDA web platform is still being rolled out. Existing RDA members PLEASE REACTIVATE YOUR ACCOUNT using this link: https://rda-login.wicketcloud.com/users/confirmation. Please report bugs, broken links and provide your feedback using the UserSnap tool on the bottom right corner of each page. Stay updated about the web site milestones at https://www.rd-alliance.org/rda-web-platform-upcoming-features-and-functionalities/.

Ethical Query on vendor lobbying in GIS/EO

  • Creator
    Discussion
  • #99058

    Suchith Anand
    Participant

    Dear colleagues
    I have ethical query on vendor lobbying/influencing and vendor sponsorship in GIS/EO education, research, projects, publications, scientific journals, scientific conferences, training and will appreciate advice. 
    I served as a Program Board member for the Group on Earth Observations (2018-2020). I currently serve as an observer to the GEO Program Board representing CODATA and International Science Council.
    I served on GEO Data Ethics Sub group (now closed by GeoSec citing “resource constraints”) where I have been raising the issue of vendor sponsorship for Group on Earth Observations (GEO) conferences, projects etc and the need to have clear guidelines.
    I have raised ethical concerns many times in GEO Program Board and different GEO committees (over 4 years now) on the issue of vendor sponsorship in GEO, rise of EO data feudalism using GEO frameworks , need for guidelines for GeoSec on vendor lobbying , code of conduct for GeoSec staff, GEO Associate members, Racial injustices etc but my ethical concerns were ignored by GeoSec. The GEO Data Ethics Sub Group  has now been closed in July 2022 by GeoSec citing “resource constraints”. 
    Why were the ethical concerns I raised over the years ignored by the GEO Secretariat ? 
    Few days back , I saw this article on vendor lobbying written by a whistleblower who worked many years at senior level for the GIS vendor who is a GEO Associate athttps://esriunearthed.substack.com/p/esri-and-jerry-lewis
    So I have ethical concerns on lobbying by GEO Associates after reading this article on vendor lobbying and request advice from colleagues with Policy expertise. Is there a code of conduct for GEO Associates?
    Are there any guidelines for scientific organisations, universities,  scientific journals to prevent vendor lobbying or influencing in publications,  projects, education initiatives, GIS curriculum, events etc ? 
    There are so many recent examples of ethical issues by GEO Associate members that GEOSec for some reason wants to ignore.
    I have raised ethical concerns on the issue of any GEO Associates (Vendor X or Y , it doesn’t matter) using “science” as part of marketing strategy for selling/promoting their products/services/brand. Is using “science” as part of marketing for selling/promoting products/services/brand by GIS vendors misinformation ? 
    http://lists.ogc.org/pipermail/geoethics/2022-August/000045.html
    Does lobbying/influencing by vendors lead to corruption? If so, is it ethical?
    Why did GEO Sec ignore (not even a public statement in the GEO website) when GEO Associate was found by U.S. Department of Labor for pay discrimination against female employees? 
    https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ofccp/ofccp20220803
    There is huge pressure to hide all these ethical issues by some organisations. 
    Ethical frameworks in governance at all levels (from global to national to local) are important to protect democracy, protect human rights and prevent corruption.
    Best wishes
    Suchith

Log in to reply.